The Iowa Public Information Board
COMES NOW, Johnathon T. Harris, Staff Attorney for the Iowa Public Information Board (āIPIBā), and enters this Investigative Report:
On July 14, 2026, Stephen Allen filed formal complaint 26FC:0180, alleging the City of Soldier violated Iowa Code chapter 22.
The IPIB accepted this Complaint on August 20, 2026.
Facts
On May 11, 2026, Complainant made a public records request to Respondent. In that request Complainant requested information related to the water lines within the City of Soldier including which houses are supplied with old style water lines listing each street and where the lines start and stop, the same for houses supplied with new water lines, records indicating the date that new water lines will be supplied to the houses that do not have them, records of any and all electric water pumps installed, and a list and detailed explanation of why Respondent refused Complainantās previous records request.
On May 13, 2026, in two emails sent to Complainant, Respondent stated āI apologize [Complainant] but we do not have records that fit your description. We considered going digital a few years ago with our files which included a full examination of the water and sewer lines. At that time, the cost was over $5,000 and the City Council did not see the benefit for our small town. We do have a very large, original map that could be copied. I donāt know if it fits your needs. Iād need to reach out to the Onawa Democrat or the Mapleton Press for copying services if they can copy that large. Let me know if youāre interested and I can seek the cost of doing so.ā
On July 23, 2026, IPIB staff opened the matter for investigation to determine if there were responsive records to Complainantās request that had not been turned over. Respondent provided a response on July 24, 2026. Respondent stated that they had been working with their city attorney to guide them through the public records request. Respondent stated that they do not have maps showing every water line in town or the materials used. Respondent stated they have an original map that has been updated manually. Respondent stated that they offered to have the map copied but had not determined the price yet because the offer had not been accepted by Complainant.
At this point IPIB staff began informal resolution efforts between the parties. IPIB staff explained that if the information does not exist in the form that it was requested in, Respondent is under no obligation to create a record, including the lists of streets. As part of the informal resolution process, IPIB staff suggested Respondent look for information that would contain the underlying information in Complainantās requests, such as emails that might include dates and locations for installation of new water lines, instead of being asked to produce new lists that do not exist.
Respondent responded that the only other records they were aware of that would show information about the makeup of the waterlines would be contained in a recent IDNR Lead Line Survey that Respondent recently participated in, but that those records were located with DNR and would need to be requested through them. Since Respondent was not the custodian, these records were not considered as āwithheldā by Respondent for the purposes of this investigation. Respondent maintained that there are no other responsive records in their custody.
Complainant was asked by IPIB Staff if the map and the IDNR records would be responsive to his records request. Complainant expressed that he continues to believe that Respondent is not being truthful when it states it does not have records detailing where the new water lines are and where the old water lines are other than the original map.
Throughout this process Complainant also stated that a bunch of water pipes were replaced not that long ago. It was determined that an engineering company that conducted some work for Respondent was in possession of some additional blueprints related to a water project. As to these additional blueprints, Respondent stated that those blueprints do not fit any of the requests in the case and that they do not address any other water lines or curb stops. However, Respondent provided these records anyway. These records were Construction Plans for a 2021 Water System Improvement for the City of Soldier, Iowa.
Despite Respondentās statement that those records were not responsive to Complainantās request, Complainant stated that the records provided were five years old and useless and he then requested āthe NEW drawings that show everything that Iām talking about. Yes, THOSE drawings. You know the drawings that actually related to the situation at hand?ā
Because the issue had boiled down to whether the response was complete, IPIB staff requested Respondent provide an affidavit describing the steps taken in response to the records request. Respondent affirmed the city clerk spoke with another employee upon receiving the records request. Respondent stated that employee confirmed to the best of his knowledge that the only documents currently in Respondentās possession are the original map and the blueprints of the 2021 water project. Respondent confirmed that as of the date of the affidavit those documents remain the only responsive documents in Respondentās possession. Respondent also affirmed that the city clerk has worked for the City of Soldier for nine years and has not seen or become aware of any additional maps, blueprints, or similar documents that would be responsive to Complainantās request.
Applicable Law
āEvery person shall have the right to examine and copy a public record and to publish or otherwise disseminate a public record or the information contained in a public record. Unless otherwise provided for by law, the right to examine a public record shall include the right to examine a public record without charge while the public record is in the physical possession of the custodian of the public record. The right to copy a public record shall include the right to make photographs or photographic copies while the public record is in the possession of the custodian of the public record. All rights under this section are in addition to the right to obtain a certified copy of a public record under section 622.46.ā Iowa Code § 22.2(1).
Analysis
The central issue in this matter is whether records exist at all. If the records do not exist, there is no requirement of Respondent to create a record with the kind of information Complainant has requested.
Chapter 22 only provides for the disclosure of existing public records. If a record does not exist, the government body is not required to create or modify a record to answer a request. For this reason, Chapter 22 does not cover general requests for information if that information is not contained in an existing public record. As an example, Chapter 22 would allow a member of the public to request a copy of a new city ordinance or emails from city officials related to that ordinance, but it would not cover a request for a list of properties affected by that ordinance (unless it was contained in an existing record). Chapter 22 Frequently Asked Questions, IPIB, (2026) https://ipib.iowa.gov/public-records/chapter-22-frequently-asked-questions-0.
Throughout the investigation and informal resolution process, it was suggested that Respondent broaden their search to determine if the underlying information that Complainant had requested existed in records possessed by Respondent but not necessarily in the organized and easy to digest form that Complainant had sought them in. The example of emails from city employees to contractors to schedule waterline installation and repair was given to Respondent to search as a possible responsive document. It was at this time that Respondent suggested the IDNR survey as a possible path towards Complainant getting the information he requested. Respondent at that time also specifically stated they do not have email exchanges with the contractors as they conduct business over the phone primarily. Because those IDNR records, if they exist, are in the custody of the Iowa DNR and not Respondent, they fall outside the scope of what Chapter 22 could require Respondent to produce in response to this request.
Complainant has argued that there is no way that Respondent only has one map which shows the locations of the waterlines and has no more information or records from any of the recent projects related to new waterline installation. While it may seem odd that there are not more records relating to the location of the waterlines, if that is true, it is not a violation. Chapter 22 has no retention requirements. Meaning if these records were created at the time the work was done, it would not be a violation for Respondent to not retain it. Respondent specifically mentioned in their initial reply to Complainant that they āconsidered going digital a few years ago with [their] files which included a full examination of the water and sewer lines. At that time, the cost was over $5,000 and the City Council did not see the benefit for [their] small town.ā While IPIB always recommends a records retention policy as best practice to avoid issues such as this one, it is not a violation of Chapter 22 to legitimately only have one responsive record to a broad records search. There has not been evidence presented that the records actually do exist. And with Respondentās admitted lack of digital retention, while there may have been many public records created throughout the process of repairing/replacing the waterlines, to not have any now is not itself a violation.
Respondentās affidavit is likewise helpful in this instance. Respondentās position from the beginning of this investigation is that the map is the only truly responsive document to Complainantās request. Respondent specifically stated that the blueprints from the engineering company were not handed over or considered because they were not considered responsive. Complainant uses the lack of responsiveness of these documents as evidence of wrongdoing by Respondent. However, Respondent essentially told Complainant the records would not be useful for his purposes but turned them over anyway amid all of the allegations of purposefully withholding responsive documents. The affidavit now has confirmed with legal assurances that Respondent simply does not have the records that Complainant has requested.
Further, asking other employees for records is not an invalid method of responding to a records request. For example, many large entities will ask council members or employees to search their own emails for records responsive to a records request. These types of methods are not per se violations simply because the records clerk themselves were not personally examining the records, particularly based on the facts of this situation.
Soldier, Iowa had 184 people as of the 2020 census. Cities of this size have very few employees, and communication is generally centralized. Respondent has stated that most of its communication is conducted over telephone, so not only are records for most things not being created, the ones that are appear to not be being retained under a set retention policy. Small towns often have very few records created and unsophisticated methods of retaining records. Without digital record keeping, records storage can take forms like a single filing cabinet or bankers boxes in the records closet. The question is not whether the city has a robust collection of records and it is not whether the city saved records that were created during construction projects. The question is whether the responsive records were offered and if the search was legally adequate. In a more sophisticated records storage system, an explanation of databases searched, search terms used, employeeās emails searched, etc. would be expected. Where a city does not have these things, they ask their employees and they look for the records physically. That is what Respondent has done here.
It is understood that Soldier, Iowa is a very small town. Perhaps a full digitization of the records does not make sense for Respondent; however, it is our suggestion that Respondent create some kind of records retention policy so citizens have a fair understanding of what Respondent plans to keep and for how long it will be kept.
Therefore, because there is insufficient evidence to show that there are records that are in Respondentās custody, are responsive to Complainantās request, and have not been offered to Complainant, there is insufficient evidence to find a violation has occurred. *
IPIB Action
The Board may take the following actions upon receipt of a probable cause report:
a. Redirect the matter for further investigation;
b. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;
c. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or
d. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.
Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4).
Recommendation
Therefore, because Respondent offered responsive records and conducted an adequate records search, there is insufficient evidence to find probable cause that a violation of Chapter 22 occurred. Therefore, it is recommended the Board dismiss for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred.
By the IPIB Staff Attorney:
_________________________
Johnathon T. Harris, J.D.
* There were many issues raised during this investigation that are outside of the scope of IPIB authority and jurisdiction. The underlying dispute involves the quality of water at Complainantās home in Soldier. IPIB does not have the authority to hear or consider any facts related to the quality of water itself, or whether the city will replace Complainantās water lines or meters. As such, this report is solely focused on the public records request and the law under Chapter 22.
CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
This document was sent on October 9, 2026, to:
Stephen Allen, Complainant
City of Solider, Respondent
The Iowa Public Information Board
Under Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4) the Board takes the following action:
āa. Redirect the matter for further investigation;
āb. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;
āc. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or
ād. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.
By the Board Chair:
___________________________________
Catherine Lucas
CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
This document was sent on October 16, 2026, to:
Stephen Allen, Complainant
City of Solider, Respondent