Topics:

Formal Complaints

The Iowa Public Information Board

In re the Matter of:

John Smith, Complainant

And Concerning:

City of Eldon, Respondent

Case Number: 26FC:0163

Investigative Report

COMES NOW, Johnathon T. Harris, Staff Attorney for the Iowa Public Information Board (“IPIB”), and enters this Investigative Report:

On June 25, 2026, John Smith “Complainant” filed formal complaint 26FC:0163, alleging the City of Eldon (“Respondent”) violated Iowa Code chapter 22.

The IPIB accepted this Complaint on July 16, 2026.

Facts

Complainant is an employee of Respondent. On June 3, 2026, Complainant was ordered to take a drug test at work. Complainant went to the testing facility but, due to concerns about procedure and the characterization of his test as “pre-employment” even though he had been an employee, did not take the test. Complainant was instructed to go home and was placed on leave pending a special city council meeting. Complainant then requested “Written documentation detailing the specific basis and reasonable suspicion for ordering the June 3 urinalysis test. All records from the testing facility, including collection logs, attempted sample volumes, technician notes, and chain-of-custody forms. Written confirmation of the administrative leave, including whether it was paid or unpaid, the reason, and the outcome of the special City Council meeting. Agendas, minutes, or summaries of any closed sessions addressing my employment status.” Complainant also requested essentially his entire personnel file. Complainant then submitted a complaint, stating that records had not been provided.

On July 9, 2026, the complaint was opened and a response was requested from Respondent. On July 15, 2026, Respondent replied with public records. These included the city drug testing policy, several meeting agendas, Complainant's application, his I-9 and W-4 forms, a jury duty form, some payroll records, and a screenshot of a phone showing a call with Complainant.

Complainant responded that he had requested his complete personnel file and the exact drug testing policy used the day his test was administered. Complainant did not find the records provided to be responsive to his request. Complainant expressed that he should be able to receive his own personnel records.

IPIB Staff explained that personnel records are categorically exempt from disclosure, except for the enumerated exceptions, asked Respondent to review the confidential records against those exceptions, and requested a response. Respondent stated on July 22, 2026, that they had provided all documents they believe are public records, but that if Complainant would come into city hall and sign a release, they would release his entire file to him. They also stated that the drug testing policy was in the handbook they previously provided.

After reviewing the drug testing policy provided by Respondent and the suggestion of picking up the records in person pursuant to another Iowa Code chapter, IPIB Staff asked Complainant whether this would satisfy his records request. Complainant stated that in-person pickup did not satisfy his request because it was not the method of inspection and copying that he had requested. He also included specifics about which personnel records and records relating to the decision to drug test him he was seeking.

Respondent stated that many of the records Complainant requested do not exist. Respondent also clarified that they were not offering the personnel file as a response to a Chapter 22 request, because there are confidential records in the file, but that he could sign a release and pick it up because it is his own file. IPIB Staff then asked Respondent about the specific records Complainant requested, asking whether it was Respondent's position that these records either do not exist or are not in the custody of the city. Respondent stated that these records specifically did not exist, several because Complainant did not actually take the test.

Complainant continued to insist there were more responsive records, at which point IPIB Staff suggested that Respondent review certain specific aspects of the records request and, if their position remained that there were no more responsive, non-confidential records to produce, that an affidavit to that effect be signed and notarized.

An affidavit signed by the city clerk and notarized was provided on September 10, 2026. It affirmed that the city had reviewed Complainant's physical file and the city email accounts to the best of their ability and confirmed there are no additional records. Respondent also affirmed that there are responsive but confidential records in Complainant's personnel file that could not be released under a records request, but that they would release the entire file if Complainant signed the release.

Complainant then provided new records requests relating to events that had occurred since the opening of the complaint. Because these are likely new requests rather than modifications, narrowings, or clarifications of the requests for which this complaint was accepted, the requests made on September 12 and 13, 2026, will not be considered as part of this report.

Applicable Law

“Every person shall have the right to examine and copy a public record and to publish or otherwise disseminate a public record or the information contained in a public record. Unless otherwise provided for by law, the right to examine a public record shall include the right to examine a public record without charge while the public record is in the physical possession of the custodian of the public record. The right to copy a public record shall include the right to make photographs or photographic copies while the public record is in the possession of the custodian of the public record. All rights under this section are in addition to the right to obtain a certified copy of a public record under section 622.46.” Iowa Code § 22.2(1)

“Personal information in confidential personnel records of government bodies relating to identified or identifiable individuals who are officials, officers, or employees of the government bodies.” Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a).

Analysis

Employee personnel records are generally categorically confidential. See 25AO:0003 - The Relationship Between Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(1)–(5) and Other Confidentiality Exceptions. While it is considered categorical there are enumerated exceptions to this rule as well. These include name and compensation, dates employed, positions held, educational and work history, the fact that a person resigned, was discharged or demoted as a result of disciplinary action and the reason and rationale for the change in employment status, the last date an individual worked for the government body, and the amount of money paid in continuation or severance. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(1)-(7).

While respondent claims that much of the personnel file sits behind that categorically confidentially, they did provide some responsive records that do include some of the exemptions required by 22.7(11)(a) (1)-(7). The provided application included Complainant’s name and compensation at $20.00 per hour, it also included his hire date as February 10, 2026. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(1) and (2). Complainant is still employed by Respondent so no end date was required to be provided. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(2). Likewise, the application included his position. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(3). The application also included his educational history, and employment history. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(4) Complainant also has not resigned, been fired, or been demoted so there would not be responsive records to that, his last day of work, or any severance records. See Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a)(5)-(7).

Based on the evidence, it appears that Respondent provided the responses they were required to under the exemptions to the general rule of confidentiality. Respondent is therefore correct that the remaining personnel file records are confidential under Iowa Code § 22.7(11)(a), and they are within their discretion to withhold the remaining personnel records under a Chapter 22 request. Respondent has also offered to provide the entire personnel file outside of the Chapter 22 request. It was even suggested by IPIB staff that Complainant pick up the personnel file as suggested, review it and then address what records he still feels are outstanding. Complainant has, as of this writing, not picked up his personnel file in person.

Next Complainant also raised concerns about a June 9th closed session that occurred and records related to that session. According to Respondent’s affidavit there are no responsive records related to that June 9th other than the recording and the agenda. Respondent stated that Complainant was present in the meeting and was provided with the agenda. Chapter 21 in addition to requiring that closed sessions be recorded, requires that detailed minutes be taken; both of which are sealed and not public records under Iowa Code § 21.5(5)(b)(1). It is therefore not a violation for Respondent to withhold the closed session records.

There is also the issue related to the testing policy and testing records. Complainant stated that the testing policy changed frequently and requested the policy that was in place the day of his test. Respondent provided the employee handbook which includes the drug testing policy. When asked directly if the policy provided in the handbook was active the day Complainant’s test was ordered, Respondent stated that it was. Respondent also later provided an updated version of the testing policy. There is no reason presented in the facts to suggest that there was another policy used to order Complainant’s drug testing. Further, any internal issues relating to the drug testing procedure are outside of IPIB jurisdiction. Based on the evidence it appears Complainant was provided with the requested record.

Respondent has provided responsive records, fulfilled their obligation to provide information consistent with 22.7(11)(a) (1)-(7), and provided for an alternate means for Complainant to receive confidential records. Based on these actions, the evidence in the case, the signed notarized affidavit affirming the search of the physical record was conducted and there are no more responsive non-confidential records, there is no violation of Chapter 22.* (*Complainant stated that the Respondent’s affidavit referred to his records request as a “FOIA request” and asked that the affidavit be redrafted to affirm that it was an Iowa Code Chapter 22 request and not a request under the Federal Freedom of Information Act. To quickly address this point, regardless of the form or wordage that Respondent used, IPIB may only interpret records requests based on Chapter 22. At no time was Complainant’s request treated as anything other than a Chapter 22 request and this analysis has only utilized Chapter 22, and opinions and cases interpreting it, as its source. Complainant’s request remains a Chapter 22 request regardless of the language used by Respondent in their affidavit.)

IPIB Action

The Board may take the following actions upon receipt of a probable cause report:

a. Redirect the matter for further investigation;

b. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;

c. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or

d. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.

Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4).

Recommendation

Because Respondent provided responsive records, followed the 22.7(11) exemptions, and has affirmed there are no more responsive records it is unlikely that there was a violation of Chapter 22. It is therefore recommended that the Board dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred.

 

By the IPIB Staff Attorney:


_______________________

Johnathon T. Harris, J.D.

 

CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

This document was sent on October 9, 2026, to:

John Smith, Complainant

City of Eldon, Respondent


The Iowa Public Information Board

In re the Matter of:

John Smith, Complainant

And Concerning:

City of Eldon, Respondent

Case Number: 26FC:0163

Probable Cause Order

Under Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4) the Board takes the following action:

☐a. Redirect the matter for further investigation;

☒b. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;

☐c. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or

☐d. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.

 

By the Board Chair

___________________________________

Catherine Lucas

CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

This document was sent on October 16, 2026, to:

John Smith, Complainant

City of Eldon, Respondent