Topics:

Formal Complaints

The Iowa Public Information Board

In re the Matter of:

Jeremy Anderson, Complainant

And Concerning:

Bettendorf Police Department, Respondent

Case Number: 26FC:0147

Investigative Report

COMES NOW, Johnathon T. Harris, Staff Attorney for the Iowa Public Information Board (“IPIB”), and enters this Investigative Report:

On May 17, 2026, Jeremy Anderson filed formal complaint 26FC:0147, alleging the Bettendorf Police Department violated Iowa Code Chapter 22.

The IPIB accepted this complaint on July 16, 2026.

Facts

Complainant submitted records requests to Respondent over several days from April 11, 2026, through April 15, 2026. The first request made on April 11, 2026 also included a report of police misconduct and requested all body-worn camera (“BWC”) footage from two specific officers during a specific time and place, all phone records and external communications made by either officer during that encounter, the complaint that initiated the call (including who called, what was reported, and the time), and the complete field intelligence report form from the encounter. The second request came on April 13, 2026, and requested “all CAD logs and dispatch records referencing” a particular license plate from January 1, 2025 through April 12, 2026, the names and badge numbers of all officers who queried that plate, all radio communications referencing the plate number or the Bettendorf Public Library on the night of April 11–12, 2026, between 11:00 p.m. and 4:00 a.m., the name and badge number of the officer operating an unmarked vehicle present in the Bettendorf Public Library parking lot during that time, all incident reports with that license plate from December 1, 2025 through April 12, 2026, and the identity of the reporting party on the complaint that initiated Complainant’s officer encounter that evening.

On April 13, 2026, Complainant sent Respondent what were essentially 34 interrogatories asking about several different topics, including department policies on police interactions, Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) policies, a document he was asked to sign, and previous complaints against a specific officer. On April 15, 2026, Complainant submitted another public records request asking for information about federal grants and civil rights compliance certifications as well as information about the ADA Coordinator for the city and police department.

Respondent first replied on April 13, 2026, stating that it was taking steps to preserve the BWC footage and other records, and it provided the incident number and the badge number of the other officer present. Respondent then stated on April 15, 2026, that it was not the possessor of the 911 records, CAD logs, or dispatch phone recordings. For the remaining records, Respondent explained the fee structure. Respondent stated the fee for the Incident/Field Intelligence Report would be $10.00. The fee for the BWC/in-car video was $20.00 per case, plus employee time for necessary redactions. The fee for all other records would be $50.00 per hour. Respondent stated at this time that it had already spent two hours searching, that the first 30 minutes would not count toward the total, and that the estimate was two additional hours. This brought the grand total to $205.00.

Also on April 15, 2026, Complainant responded to Respondent’s fee proposal. The response included an outright rejection of the fee estimate. Complainant stated he was formally requesting a full waiver of all fees. Complainant stated he felt that Respondent’s previous email indicated he was being charged extra for submitting the requests through multiple emails, which Complainant stated violated his ADA rights (email communication is a recognized disability accommodation for Complainant’s disability).

Respondent then stated on April 16, 2026, that it was following Chapter 22 and that, if Complainant was willing to pay the fee, it would resume the search.

On April 20, 2026, Complainant requested an itemized breakdown of the fees being assessed and asked whether fees had been applied to non-disabled requesters.

On April 29, 2026, Respondent stated the fees would not be waived and cited IPIB Advisory Opinion 21AO:0006 as the justification for the fees.

After further correspondence on issues related to ADA accommodations, which are outside the scope of this investigation, Complainant filed the present complaint on May 17, 2026, alleging that the fee estimate provided by Respondent was unlawful.

After the complaint was filed, on June 2, 2026, the ADA Coordinator responded to Complainant’s ADA grievance with information relevant to this investigation. First, Respondent stated it would waive the fees for the Incident/Field Intelligence Report, the BWC footage and a ban notice that was also responsive. It also stated it would lower the rate to $30.00 per hour, which would bring the new total to $105.00. Respondent also stated that there was no additional charge based on Complainant’s emails or disability status. Respondent stated the records were being searched for by an individual who actually makes over $62.00 per hour and that the $50.00 per hour charge was already lower than actual cost.

IPIB staff opened the complaint for investigation and requested a response from Respondent. On June 26, 2026, Respondent provided a position statement, timeline, and emails, the bulk of which has already been explained above. Also included in Respondent’s response was an affidavit, signed and notarized, from Respondent’s employee who conducted the search. The employee stated that they are the lawful custodian of police records, that they based the fee estimate on their own time because of the scope and complexity of the requests, and that there was no surcharge or additional cost assigned because of Complainant’s email communication accommodation.

Upon review of all the facts, IPIB staff initiated informal resolution discussions based on the following conclusions: (1) the flat fees assigned for the production of the Incident/Field Intelligence Report and the BWC footage likely violated Chapter 22’s fee provisions; (2) the hourly fee assigned originally was likely not a violation because it was derived from the actual projected costs of production; (3) other issues raised in this matter are not within IPIB’s jurisdiction, including the ADA concerns and any dispute as to the actual conduct of the officers in question; and (4) Chapter 22 does not require a waiver of fees. Therefore, on July 23, 2026, IPIB staff proposed an informal resolution with the following terms:

  1. The Respondent acknowledges that a violation of Iowa Chapter Code 22 occurred on April 15, 2026.
  2. The Respondent will amend their Iowa Code Chapter 22 policy to comply with the fee requirements of Iowa Code Chapter 22. This amended policy will specifically provide that all costs assigned to requesters must be related to the actual cost of production of requested documents. A copy will be provided to IPIB for review.
  3. The Respondent will provide Complainant with a fee estimate that only considers the actual cost of production of records.

Complainant then requested three amendments also on July 23, 2026. First, Complainant specified his records request for resolution purposes:

  1. all incident and field intelligence reports for the April 11, 2026 encounter (Incident No. 2026-8336) and the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter, including Officer Claussen’s report of the April 11 encounter; (b) all body-worn camera footage from both encounters; (c) all in-car/dash camera footage and audio from every unit, marked or unmarked, that was present at or captured [Complainant’s] vehicle at any location on October 16, 2025, or from April 11, 2026 through the early morning hours of April 12, 2026, including but not limited to the Kwik Star, the Bettendorf Public Library, and Crow Creek Park; (d) CAD/dispatch logs for October 16, 2025 and for April 11 through April 12, 2026, reflecting all units dispatched to or logging activity at the locations above; and (e) records sufficient to identify the officer involved in the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter.

Complainant then requested that the fees be waived as a negotiated term, while acknowledging that it is not a required step under Chapter 22. Complainant also requested that a term be added limiting the scope of the agreement to the present complaint only.

Respondent replied with a revised version of the agreement on July 31, 2026. In the revised agreement, Respondent noted that it had already waived the flat fees on June 2, 2026, and it incorporated both the list provided by Complainant and the limited scope of the agreement:

  1. The Respondent acknowledges that a potential violation of Iowa Code Chapter 22 occurred on April 15, 2026, regarding flat fees of $10 for incident/field intelligence reports and $20 for body camera/dash camera footage
  2. The Respondent has amended its Iowa Code Chapter 22 policy to comply with the fee requirements of Iowa Code Chapter 22 and to remove the $10 and $20 dollar flat fees, said amendment being made on May 15, 2026. This amendment provides that all costs assigned to requesters, making requests under Iowa Code Chapter 22, must be related to the actual cost of production of requested documents. A copy of the amended policy is hereby provided to IPIB for review. The Respondent removed the $10 and $20 flat fees form its amended estimate provided to Complainant on June 2, 2026.
  3. As part of this informal resolution process, Complainant has narrowed his records request, and Respondent will provide a substantive response at no cost for the following items: (a) all incident and field intelligence reports for the April 11, 2026 encounter (Incident No. 2026-8336) and the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter, including Officer Claussen’s report of the April 11 encounter; (b) all body-worn camera footage from both encounters; (c) all in-car/dash camera footage and audio from every unit, marked or unmarked, that was present at or captured [Complainant’s] vehicle at any location on October 16, 2025, or from April 11, 2026 through the early morning hours of April 12, 2026, including but not limited to the Kwik Star, the Bettendorf Public Library, and Crow Creek Park; (d) CAD/dispatch logs for October 16, 2025 and for April 11 through April 12, 2026, reflecting all units dispatched to or logging activity at the locations above; and (e) records sufficient to identify the officer involved in the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter. All other records requests from Complainant are withdrawn.
  4. This informal Resolution resolves the Iowa Code Chapter 22 fee matter presented in 26FC:0147, and does not waive, release, or affect any other claim, complaint, or proceeding, including, without limitation, Iowa Civil Rights Commission Complaint CP#85504.

Upon receiving that amended proposal, also on July 31, 2026, Complainant stated “I am withdrawing my proposed amendments to the informal Resolution, submitted July 23, 2026 effective immediately. Nothing in that submission (July 23, 2026) remains on the table as my amended proposal to move this forward. My request before the board still stands.” Complainant explained that he was withdrawing because Respondent’s proposal was not made in good faith, because it characterized the informal resolution terms proposed by Complainant as an amended records request, and because production was not binding, as the agreement promised only a “substantive response.” Complainant also requested a brief extension in the proceedings to retain counsel.

As a last attempt to reach an informal resolution, and after discussing Complainant’s concerns with the agreement proposed by Respondent, IPIB staff prepared a third version of the agreement on August 12, 2026:

  1. The Respondent acknowledges that a potential violation of Iowa Code Chapter 22 occurred on April 15, 2026, regarding flat fess of $10 for incident/field intelligence reports and $20 for body camera/dash camera footage.
  2. The Respondent has amended its Iowa Code Chapter 22 policy to comply with the fee requirements of Iowa Code Chapter 22 and to remove the $10- and $20-dollar flat fees, said amendment being made on May 15, 2026. This amendment provides that all costs assigned to requesters, making requests under Iowa Code Chapter 22, must be related to the actual cost of production of requested documents. A copy of the amended policy is hereby provided to IPIB for review. The Respondent removed the $10 and $20 flat fees form its amended estimate provided to Complainant on June 2, 2026.
  3. Respondent will provide all non-confidential records at no cost responsive to the follow items: (a) all incident and field intelligence reports for the April 11, 2026 encounter (Incident No. 2026-8336) and the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter, including Officer Claussen’s report of the April 11 encounter; (b) all body-worn camera footage from both encounters; (c) all in-car/dash camera footage and audio from every unit, marked or unmarked, that was present at or captured [Complainant’s] vehicle at any location on October 16, 2025, or from April 11, 2026 through the early morning hours of April 12, 2026, including but not limited to the Kwik Star, the Bettendorf Public Library, and Crow Creek Park; (d) CAD/dispatch logs for October 16, 2025 and for April 11 through April 12, 2026, reflecting all units dispatched to or logging activity at the locations above; and (e) records sufficient to identify the officer involved in the October 16, 2025 Crow Creek Park encounter. Records found containing both confidential and non-confidential materials will still be provided with redactions.
  4. This informal Resolution resolves the Iowa Code Chapter 22 fee matter presented in 26FC:0147, and does not waive, release, or affect any other claim, complaint, or proceeding, including, without limitation, Iowa Civil Rights Commission Complaint CP#85504., or any existing records retention obligations of the Respondent.

After taking the brief extension, Complainant on August 27, 2026, suggested three more amendments after receiving the amended proposal from IPIB staff: (1) replacing “will provide” in term 3 with “will produce and deliver to Complainant,” (2) adding a 30-day execution timeline, and (3) requiring Respondent to provide an index of any withheld records.

Respondent replied on September 9, 2026, accepting the amendments proposed by Complainant, and additionally stated the following:

I do want to clarify that the City does not possess any documents relating to: (1) an October 16, 2025 encounter at Crow Creek Park, or (2) an encounter in the early morning hours of April 12, 2026 at the Bettendorf Library. No calls for service or officer-initiated incidents were created involving [Complainant] on these dates/locations nor were there any BWC or squad video recordings of encounters involving [Complainant] on these dates/locations. Additionally, the City/PD is not the possessor of the 911 recordings, CAD logs, or dispatch for recordings (referenced in Section 3(d) of the proposed resolution). These records are held by the Scott County Emergency Communications Center (SECC). The City previously informed [Complainant] of the fact that SECC holds such documents.

At this point, also on September 9, 2026, Complainant withdrew his support for the informal agreement. Because an agreement had been reached and then withdrawn, and multiple rounds of informal resolution had occurred, IPIB staff moved forward with this Investigative Report.

Applicable Law

“Fulfillment of a request for a copy of a public record may be contingent upon receipt of payment of reasonable expenses. The lawful custodian shall make every reasonable effort to provide the public record requested at no cost other than copying costs for a record which takes less than thirty minutes to produce.” Iowa Code § 22.3(2)(a).

Analysis

There are essentially three issues within IPIB’s jurisdiction presented by the facts of this case, all related to proper fee assessment. The first is whether the flat fees assigned by Respondent were lawful; the second is whether the hourly fee was lawful; and the third is whether Respondent was required to waive fees.

To begin, flat fees are normally unlawful under Chapter 22. “If the lawful custodian charges a fee to respond to a records request, that fee must be based on actual, direct costs associated with making and providing copies. Actual costs may include considerations such as the cost of printing or the hourly rates of the employee(s) involved in responding to a records request, but it should not include indirect costs like electricity or insurance.” Chapter 22 Frequently Asked Questions, IPIB (2026), https://ipib.iowa.gov/public-records/chapter-22-frequently-asked-questions-0. Flat fees are inherently not based on the actual cost of production of the records. Therefore, the flat fees initially assigned by Respondent likely violated Chapter 22. However, that issue has been resolved both in the present complaint and for the future. On June 2, 2026, Respondent waived the flat fees assigned to Complainant when it provided Complainant the updated $105.00 fee estimate and later agreed to waive all fees as part of the informal resolution process. Respondent also revised its fee policy. The new fee policy provides a flat fee only for Accident/Collision/Crash Reports, in the amount of $10.00, to be requested through CrashDocs.org. Fees for all other records are based on employees’ hourly rates, as required by Chapter 22.

On the issue of the hourly fee rate assigned, it is unlikely that a violation has taken place. First, there is no requirement in Chapter 22 that a lower-paid employee conduct the searches. If the employee actually conducting the search makes $62.00 per hour, charging $50.00 per hour is not unreasonable and does not exceed the actual cost of production. In fact, the initial estimate was based on a rate below what the employee actually earned, and Respondent later lowered the rate to $30.00 per hour and then waived all fees. There is nothing in Chapter 22 that makes a fee unreasonable simply because it is high; however, higher fees will always be subject to somewhat more scrutiny because of the potential barrier to access to public records. In this instance, the hourly fee estimate was based on the work already performed, the rate at which it was performed, and the estimated time to complete the search. Therefore, the hourly fee, both as initially assessed and as amended, did not violate Chapter 22.

Advisory Opinion 21AO:0006 states “Iowa Code chapter 22 is silent on the issue of the waiving of any authorized fees. There is no requirement within Chapter 22 for a government body to waive the collection of its authorized fees prior to the fulfillment of a public record request.” As Complainant pointed out, the first portion of that opinion concerns special meetings. The relevant portion here, however, asks only whether any situation requires a city to waive its open records fees, regardless of context. Thus, there is no requirement for a governmental body to waive its reasonable fees, and it was therefore not a violation for Respondent to initially refuse to do so, even though Respondent ultimately offered to waive its fees.

Overall, even though Respondent first provided an unlawful fee agreement, throughout the process they lowered the fee estimate, then removed it, they have changed their written fee structure to remove the offending fees, and even agreed to provide a privilege log which is not required under Chapter 22. Respondent has shown good faith in attempting to reach an agreement with Complainant on the matter of the fees.

No fee issues remain before IPIB in this matter. The only portion of the fee proposal that was likely unlawful consisted of the flat fees, which have been waived, and the policy that allowed them has been changed. Respondent later dropped all fees after receiving Complainant’s narrowed scope of production as part of the informal resolution process. That Respondent does not possess many of the records Complainant requested, is not a violation.

IPIB Action

The Board may take the following actions upon receipt of a probable cause report:

a. Redirect the matter for further investigation;

b. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;

c. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or

d. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.

Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4).

Recommendation

Respondent has remedied the fee issue for which this matter was accepted, revised its policy so that flat fees are no longer assigned (other than for crash reports), and has offered to produce the responsive records. Therefore, because the flat fees likely violated Chapter 22 and that violation has now been remedied, IPIB staff recommends that the Board make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter.

By the IPIB Staff Attorney,

_________________________

Johnathon T. Harris, J.D.

CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

This document was sent on October 8, 2026, to:

Jeremy Anderson, Complainant

Christopher J. Curran, Attorney for Respondent


The Iowa Public Information Board

In re the Matter of:

Jeremy Anderson, Complainant

And Concerning:

Bettendorf Police Department, Respondent

Case Number: 26FC:0147

Probable Cause Order

 

Under Iowa Admin. Code r. 497-2.2(4) the Board takes the following action:

☐a. Redirect the matter for further investigation;

☐b. Dismiss the matter for lack of probable cause to believe a violation has occurred;

☒c. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, but, as an exercise of administrative discretion, dismiss the matter; or

☐d. Make a determination that probable cause exists to believe a violation has occurred, designate a prosecutor and direct the issuance of a statement of charges to initiate a contested case proceeding.

 

By the Board Chair

___________________________________

Catherine Lucas

CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

This document was sent on October 16, 2026, to:

Jeremy Anderson, Complainant

Bettendorf Police Department, Respondent